Comments on: Remember this is a family friendly blog

By: Lucian Coffey

Lucian Coffey — Tue, 24 Mar 2009 23:54:46 +0000

My favorite amercian idol of all time! XD

By: Eric Peterson

Eric Peterson — Mon, 05 May 2008 20:41:47 +0000

I hated to see Brooke go, but that’s okay. The star (David Cook) is still here! I’m with Jay on this one, in that I’d buy a “Brooke behind the piano” cd. Of course, I’ll probably get David Cook’s as well, which is saying a lot since I don’t usually go out and buy the “Idol CD’s”.

April,
On a side note, I do want to point out that in my previous comment, I stated that the TWO DAVIDS would be in the finals. I thought the final 5 would go down like this:

Syesha -(I missed this one)
Brooke
Jason – final three
David Arch – final two
David Cook – winner

However, if I were judging, I would have had Brooke and David Cook in the finals (although I’d probably revise that now, as Brooke did struggle the last week or two and Syesha has really come out and proven herself).

By: Creechman

Creechman — Sun, 04 May 2008 10:40:53 +0000

I’m going to have to pick it up to do better than -4. :/

By: Kirsten Harrell, Psy.D.

Kirsten Harrell, Psy.D. — Fri, 02 May 2008 14:42:12 +0000

I was very sad to see Brooke go. I really love the sound of her voice. I know she is sort of hit or miss, but when she’s on… she is smokin hot! However, I can’t complain too much because I don’t vote.

As for Paula… perhaps she should get a 900 psychic hotline!

By: Coach Coco

Coach Coco — Thu, 01 May 2008 21:30:36 +0000

Okay, Jason is the dark horse on this. It is his looks and age that have gotten him where he is at.

Not surprised to see Carly gone… she picked the wrong song… I stand with “Don’t Cry for Me Argentina” was a much better choice for her.

David Cook is starting to make me think of Pearl Jam and David Archuleta is like a Donny Osmond done over… David (one of them) is going to win it… Syesha is likely gone next show… unless Jason makes song choices like Brooke.

Cook or Archuleta?? Cook needs a band… Archuleta needs a Disney Show.. if Miley wasn’t in such deep trouble now – I would say the two would make the ideal Disney Movie couple.

Either way – the winner should have been Johns.

Toodles.

By: Jay Thompson

Jay Thompson — Thu, 01 May 2008 14:08:45 +0000

Well, Brooke is gone. I liked her, but I honestly think the pressure of another week would have made her head explode. I would buy a CD of her behind the piano tomorrow. But she probably needs to stick to studio recordings and avoid live performances.

Jason handles the pressure well because I don’t think Jason even knows where he is half the time. Smoking bowl after bowl of weed will do that to you. He really needs to go next week.

Sayesha will be singing on Broadway within a year.

David Cook should win, but the force of the pink phone is strong in young Archuleta. It will be close, probably Ruben/Clay like close. The finale will have Seacrest saying, “You new American Idol is David …….. (insert agonizingly long pause here. Cut to each fidgeting and sighing and looking at each other)………. Cook!”

Now, how can I not say anything about Paula’s big giant F-up. WTH? How can anyone be so stupid? I wish they’d give her a phone number and let us vote her off. I didn’t think it was possible but she just annoys me more and more each week.

By: Savannah Red

Savannah Red — Thu, 01 May 2008 11:17:00 +0000

I’m ashamed to say it, but once I realized that it was going to be “Reverend Blue Jeans” week, I scooted over to the NBA and stayed.

Brooke needed to go–everytime I saw her recently, it looked like she was either getting ready for a big cry or was just finishing one. I’m sure there is an Aging Emo chapter for her where she’s from.

I expect it will come down to the Davids, with Cook wearing his AC bracelet, jacket, guitar, and crucifix, to vanquish Archuleta, one of Sauron’s prettier looking Orcs.